I am so very, very happy that I made an exception for this book. I usually don’t read prequels, especially if I know that someone doesn’t last through the series – especially because of a bad end. Then, we meet a very young and very mischievous John Dallington. Graham, of course, is one of my favorite people. She’s married to someone else and Charles is heartbroken over that. It was fun to meet the younger, more immature versions of people we’ll get to know and love throughout the series. I loved the descriptions of his fence painting – and I loved that when he finally spoke to Charles about his leaving them he said – “The hardest part of losing a person, Charles, is that grief is only an absence. I absolutely adored his father and the efforts he made to ensure that he spent time with each of the family members individually and that they knew he loved them. How Charles, his mother, and brother Edmund – his father too – deal with that is so bittersweet and lovely. We meet Charles’ mother and father and learn of the father, Edward’s, medical diagnosis. Those are skillfully written and poignant, heartwarming, emotional and sad.

While the murder plot was interesting, detailed and engrossing, I think my favorite parts of the book were the more personal parts.

As he digs and learns more and more – he shares it all with Scotland Yard. Of course, Scotland Yard wants no part of their help, but that doesn’t deter Charles. They are off to Scotland Yard to show them their conjecture and to offer their services. He and his valet, Graham, use the timeline given in the letter and find the case the letter writer must be claiming as his perfect crime. When one of those newspapers carry the text of a letter claiming that the writer had already committed one ‘perfect’ murder and would be committing another soon, Charles knew he had to be involved. He does that by buying copies of all of the newspapers and cutting all of the crime related articles out and filing them away. However, being the tenacious young man that he is, Charles perseveres by honing his knowledge of crimes in London, how they are solved and the details behind them. He desperately wants to be a detective, but his few forays into it and his interactions with Scotland Yard have been very disappointing. We are introduced to a young Charles Lenox, just twenty-three years of age and newly living in London on his own. The writing is superb, the characters are fully developed and relatable, and the story is fast-paced, engrossing and detailed. While it is shown as book #0 in the series because it is a prequel, it is actually something like the thirteenth if you count the novellas. This has to be the absolute best book of the Charles Lenox Mystery series so far.

WOW! I am in awe of Charles Finch and his writing and I’d give this book more than 5-stars if I could.

Charles finch the woman in the water